Andre Collin
This is how I feel after every rejection letter

Job searching is tough and rejection hurts. I feel it too!

Publication date: April 29, 2025

The emotional cost of rejection

I’ve been job searching for a while now, and I’ll be honest: it’s exhausting in a way that’s hard to explain until you’re in it.

Every rejection lands differently. Some are easy to move past. Others hit you on the wrong day and send you into a spiral of “maybe I’m not actually as good as I thought I was.” The silence is worse: when an application vanishes without even a polite no, you don’t get closure. You just sit with the uncertainty.

Recently, after an interview I thought had gone well, the rejection knocked me sideways for a few days. I genuinely believed I would have done well in that role. For a while after, I started second-guessing things I’d felt certain about. Not just my interview performance, but my judgment, my skills, my read on what I bring to a team.

Job searching doesn’t just test your marketability. It tests your sense of yourself.

What I’ve actually changed

Over time, I’ve stopped treating every rejection as evidence about my worth and started looking at it more practically.

A lot of what filters applications at the first stage has nothing to do with skill. Applicant Tracking Systems parse resumes against job descriptions for keyword matches. If the phrasing you used for a skill doesn’t match the phrasing in the posting, your application might not surface even when the underlying experience is a strong fit. I’ve started tailoring my resume language to match each role’s specific wording, not stuffing keywords, but genuinely translating my experience into the language the role uses. The difference in callback rate was noticeable.

Some rejections come down to fit factors I couldn’t have anticipated: budget changed, internal candidate surfaced, team went a different direction. You can do everything right and still not get the role. That’s not a signal about you. It’s a signal about the particular combination of circumstances at that company at that moment.

Understanding that doesn’t make rejection painless. But it makes it less personal.

Reaching out is harder than it sounds but worth it

When I started being more open with my network about the search, I expected it to feel awkward. It mostly didn’t.

Most people I reached out to, old colleagues, people I’d worked adjacent to, connections I hadn’t spoken to in months, responded with genuine warmth. They shared leads, made introductions, offered to review materials, or just replied with encouragement that arrived on a day when I needed it. A few conversations led directly to interviews I wouldn’t have had otherwise.

What helped was keeping the outreach honest and low-pressure: not asking for jobs, just letting people know I was looking and asking if they had any thoughts. Most people have been in a job search. They remember how it feels.

Isolation is one of the easiest traps in a job search. Rejection accumulates, the work feels lonely, and the instinct to withdraw is strong. But the conversations that helped me most were usually the ones I almost didn’t start.

What I’m still figuring out

I don’t have a tidy conclusion here, because I’m still in this. I’m still submitting applications, still waiting on responses, still processing the occasional rejection that hits harder than it should.

What I know is that staying in motion helps more than staying in my head. Revising the resume, making one more connection, preparing more concretely for the next interview: these are things I can control. The outcome of any single application is not.

If you’re in this too, you already know it’s harder than it looks from the outside. The people asking “have you tried LinkedIn?” have not recently experienced what it’s like to apply to 40 roles and hear back from six. Be honest about what you need, give yourself permission to rest when the energy runs out, and trust that the accumulation of small efforts is doing something even when it doesn’t feel like it.

You’re not alone in this. Neither am I.

job searchrejectionnetworkingATSresumesupportmental healthconfidencecareer growthresilienceinterview